Monday, September 2, 2013

The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones movie review

On Sunday I had the opportunity to watch The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones with a friend and her husband. My friend and I had both read the book while her husband had not. She told him that it was like a mix of Harry Potter and Twilight. What did we think of it?

I wasn't originally planning to see the movie in the theater. While I really enjoyed the first three books in the series I felt let down by City of Fallen Angels and never read City of Lost Souls. After seeing the trailer however, I changed my mind. I was really looking forward to seeing the movie though I figured that it would have flaws and changes from the book. Then came all the negative reviews and suddenly I wasn't so keen to see it anymore but I went anyway.

While there are changes (and it has been a few years since I read the book so I didn't pick up on all of them) I thought the spirit of the book was there and I really liked the portrayals of the characters particularly Clary, Jace, and Simon. I had my doubts about Jamie Campbell Bower but I thought he made an acceptable Jace. Lily Collins was a pretty good Clary too. I wasn't a fan of hers after seeing Mirror Mirror but thought she did a nice job here. I was really surprised by how much I liked Robert Sheehan as Simon. He really made Simon's emotions believable as well as providing some nice comic relief. It was also great to see the talented Lena Headey as Jocelyn. She even had a few action scenes that she didn't get in the book. While I appreciated the creepiness of Jonathan Rhys Meyers, I thought he came across as an over the top cult leader type rather than the intelligent and cunning Valentine of the book.

It was fun to see the world of the Shadowhunters come to life although I was disappointed by the party at Magnus Bane's and the whole vampire story line with Simon. There are definitely changes from the book and I recommend strongly that you wait to read or reread the book till after you've seen the movie if things like that really bug you. 

If you go into the theater expecting a movie that will be different from the book and don't have Hunger Games level expectations for it, then you might enjoy it. My friend and I both really liked it and her husband thought it was better than Twilight and the Harry Potter films. I agree about Twilight but I think that the Harry Potter films are better (even though they also have flaws.) 

I am glad that I chose to go and see the movie even with the bad reviews and I think I will enjoy the sequel if it is made. I have also been inspired to reread the series and give the newer books a chance. It is hard to adapt a book for film and get it right and while City of Bones may not completely succeed, it was still a fun and entertaining film. 


  1. I can't imagine this being better than HP...not familiar with the books but I will totally watch this when it shows up on TV.

  2. Thanks for stopping by today, Christina. You confirmed that I"m on the right wave length about this story! So much of what you said follows my thoughts about it. Ha!

    I thought I saw bite marks on Simon and thought he might even turn into a vampire, but nothing came of it, at least in this segment. Maybe that will get some play in the next film. It felt like a thread that was left hanging. I wasn't sorry, though because the Simon character is so sweet, I didn't want anything bad to happen to

    We'll have to check in again to see what we think of part two. I may wait to read that second book until then as you suggested so I don't get mad if they make changes I don't I did read The Hunger Games before seeing the movie and in that case, I"m glad I did. I wouldn't have had a clue about what the opening scene was about if I hadn't, it was so convoluted.

    Stay in touch. :-)

  3. Glad to hear that Lily Collins did better in this film than she did in Mirror, Mirror. I'm hoping to see the film this weekend!

  4. I felt much the same about the movie as you did. I haven't read the book in years, so I didn't pick up on every single flaw like I usually do. (I think that may have made it a little more enjoyable for me. haha!) I liked Jamie as Jace, I just wished that would have made him a little more sarcastic, like in the books. I really, really liked Simon! I am looking forward to seeing more of him in the next few movies. :)
    Great review!


Reading Extensively is now an award free blog. Thanks for stopping by! Please leave a comment. I enjoy receiving feedback! Due to increase in spam, I've enabled comment moderation. Sorry for any inconvenience!